Community Site
HomeLinksNewsFixturesLogs & ResultsClub InfoGallerySite infoSocial MediaCape Rugby TVSign InEvox SponsorshipChat Zone
 
Chat Zone WP Club Rugby - Chat Zone
WP Club Rugby > Chat Zone > Cape Malay Tournament View modes: 
User avatar
Senior Member
Senior Member
Planki - 28/06/2011 09:40:46
   
Cape Malay Tournament
What we should do is arrange a tournament at the end of Ramadaan for all senior teams. All the Malay teams in the various wp club rugby leagues should be invited. When the tournament is complete, we select a squad of 30 of the best players and at the end of the year/beginning of the year , they go on a tour to play in various other provinces. This way we all connect with each other. What do you guys think? I know this will be hard to organise, but seeing that our season is ending is such a hurry due to the fast, we can play our own tournament afterwards. Maybe it could prolong over two weeks. You play on Wednesday/Friday/Saturday and Sunday. It could be played at the GreenPoint track.

SKW
Collegians
Primroses
Rangers
Hamediahs
Violets
MIT Rangers
Caledonian Roses
Watsonia
Silvertree
Young Stars
For the Love of Rugby!!!

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Josh K - 28/06/2011 09:51:31
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
What would the purpose be ??? sounds like a waste of time.
Josh Kronfeld - half man half machine - A legend

User avatar
Coach
Coach
Mo2010 - 28/06/2011 09:53:13
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
 That will be a good idea, but I know some of the clubs have a couple of games after the Ramadaan. So they wont be able to partake immediately

User avatar
Senior Member
Senior Member
Planki - 28/06/2011 10:15:53
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
It seems you losing your sense of unity Josh K. THis is just so that families can come together and watch rugby, Families playing rugby against each other etc..
We can do it to raise money for Orphans or any charity's etc...
For the Love of Rugby!!!

User avatar
Coach
Coach
Gamat - 28/06/2011 10:21:54
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
It sounds like it could be a very nice event, old school rivalries.

The only major problem is that i dont think u can exclude clubs based on ethnicity. The jive cricket tournament had the same problem.

Sure would have been very  interesting.


User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
capeflats - 28/06/2011 10:48:03
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
This would be an exclusive APARTHEID style tournament

How would we react if all the white clubs had a tournament amongst themselves?

Shit idea
"Rugby is LIFE, all else is mere Detail"

User avatar
Coach
Coach
Gamat - 28/06/2011 10:59:27
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament

I think you a bit harsh on Planki. His intention it seems was building of community spirit and not Apartheid style exclusion.

I agree that such a tournament will be discrimanatory and you going to need a fairly decent chap to prove in court of law that it is not unfair discrimination.

BUT, why not re-invent rag days. Clubs are allowed to invite old rivals and play against them.


User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Josh K - 28/06/2011 11:19:28
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
Planki speaks of unity .. and wants to base this whole thing on colour, but when we speak of the unfairness that still exists today he is the one that wets his broek about people having to move on and get on with things.

We dont need a tournament like that to create unity ... what we need to do is to support our clubs properly and making that a place for family and friends ...
Josh Kronfeld - half man half machine - A legend

User avatar
Newbie
Newbie
Akka - 28/06/2011 11:37:49
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament

Planki.With respect, you appear to suffer from a "Apartheid" hang-over.Wake up to our new S.A...Think broader and 'inclusive'..there are many other ways to acheive the results and benefits you're looking for.

User avatar
Coach
Coach
kappa - 28/06/2011 12:02:10
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
Im sure Planki didnt mean it as it seems..... Such tournaments are held over Easter in East London and even Langa and many other places with only "Black Clubs", and nobody has anything to say about it. Those ''Day of Rugby'' stuff that used to be held on Sundays on the Track, no longer works in my opinion.

User avatar
Senior Member
Senior Member
Planki - 28/06/2011 12:10:41
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
I do apologise if I offended anyone, this is not a race issue. This idea was just to uplift our community with rugby and intergrate it with religion. As mentioned  in my post, I did ask "what do you think".  I am not one to talk about race people. Maybe it is one dimensional, but I truly meant in a good aspect.
For the Love of Rugby!!!

User avatar
Coach
Coach
kappa - 28/06/2011 12:13:42
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
Planki wrote: I do apologise if I offended anyone, this is not a race issue. This idea was just to uplift our community with rugby and intergrate it with religion. As mentioned  in my post, I did ask "what do you think".  I am not one to talk about race people. Maybe it is one dimensional, but I truly meant in a good aspect.



User avatar
Newbie
Newbie
Akka - 28/06/2011 12:30:38
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
Well, if it is a regional tournament and there happens to be only 'black clubs' within the region then it stands to reason, that for logistical reasons, only those clubs are invited...If that is not the case then it unfortunate remains a racist one ..whether it has a only 'black', only 'malay' , only 'coloured' or only 'white' flavour to it. 

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
jakes actually - 28/06/2011 13:27:10
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
Josh K wrote: What would the purpose be ??? sounds like a waste of time.



Shame Josh, you pissed on his parade!!


User avatar
Coach
Coach
Samwell Part 4 - 28/06/2011 14:00:06
   
RE:Cape Malay Tournament
Kloof het dan net 5/6 "malays" in die first team starting line-up saterdag teen Durbell. gehad :-)

And what about Vineyards? Are we "Paarl" malay of is die Moerate nie "malays" nie LOL!

On a serious note, one of my companies, Al-Isra is a muslim organisation and we wanted to do this next year. Al-isra would then sponsor each team with his playing strip and warm up kit for that weekend and the season if they want to continue using it. Budget is R5 000 per club so a decent jersey can be made for the 10 clubs invited. This will form part of our compulsary charity portion as we have to give to "muslim" organisations. Will that be creating an apartheid "vibe"? Interseting... I am glad this topic came to the front as I was about to apraoch these clubs.

But by the resopnse here, maybe I should can that idea???
Coauld be more negative than positive.

1 2
Search forums: 

171 user(s) on-line: 0 registered and 171 guest(s)

Bookmark this page to:Add to Yahoo Bookmarks Add to Facebook Add to Ask Add to Blogmarks Add to Simpy Add to MyAOL Add to Delicious Add to Multiply Add to Link-a-Gogo Add to Faves Add to Twitter Add to Live Add to Furl Add to Mixx Add to Segnalo Add to Reddit Add to Terchnorati Add to StumbleUpon Add to Digg Add to Slashdot Add to Spurl Add to Yahoo MyWeb Add to Newsvine Add to MySpace Add to Diigo Add to Backflip Add to Mister Wong Add to Google Bookmarks

New - One price ADSL R169.00 - GET IT! - Cybersmart Internet Service Provider.

This web site uses Kentico CMS, the content management system for ASP.NET developers. Western Province Club Rugby