Community Site
HomeLinksNewsFixturesLogs & ResultsClub InfoGallerySite infoSocial MediaCape Rugby TVSign InEvox SponsorshipChat Zone
 
Chat Zone WP Club Rugby - Chat Zone
WP Club Rugby > Chat Zone > Was the Welsh penalty over or not? View modes: 
User avatar
Coach
Coach
eagle - 12/09/2011 12:55:54
   
Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
By looking at the replay it would appear that the penalty kick from Hook was over.If it was awarded, then we would have had a shocker of an opening from our boys!

User avatar
Groupie
Groupie
Hayco - 12/09/2011 13:49:17
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
Eagle
Nope - that was not over

User avatar
Groupie
Groupie
Maverick12 - 12/09/2011 14:39:13
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
Definately NOT over. Would've hit the outside of the post if it were a bit longer. Hook has himself to blame - It was a simple kick which he should've nailed easily.

User avatar
Coach
Coach
eagle - 12/09/2011 14:55:04
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
I am glad it was not awarded, but if you look carefully at the replay, it appeared to pass just inside the right-hand upright.

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Josh K - 12/09/2011 15:28:18
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?

Kick was good .. rugby terms .. it was good , however its no use to dwell on that , wasnt given, plus they had chances to seal it and they didnt ..Im a bit worried that ref decisions are going to cost teams big-time ..

Josh Kronfeld - half man half machine - A legend

User avatar
Old Crock
Old Crock
paddy - 12/09/2011 16:15:53
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
Just watched it again. One needs another angle to determine at what point the ball curved inwards.

User avatar
Coach
Coach
eagle - 12/09/2011 16:36:03
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
I agree with you Paddy.It could have curved inwards behind the post and I think that's how the assistant refs saw it.

User avatar
Groupie
Groupie
The1 - 12/09/2011 19:32:50
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
Paddy & Eagle - I agree with you 100%.  I dont even know why this post was even started.  One has to look at another angle first before one can make a call. 

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
jakes actually - 14/09/2011 08:00:34
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
Referees and assistants blow on what they see, apparently! I for one looking at the replays on offer, believe it may well have gone over.

User avatar
Coach
Coach
_Slegend_ - 14/09/2011 10:30:16
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
Who cares!!! This time we did win it according to the scoreboard

User avatar
Coach
Coach
eagle - 14/09/2011 12:45:12
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
Hi Slegend, I think you would have cared a lot if it was awarded insisting that the TMO should have been used

User avatar
Old Crock
Old Crock
sparty - 19/09/2011 09:05:08
   
RE:Was the Welsh penalty over or not?
 I thought at the time the kick was over but I was out at Kaprino's that morning and it was noisy , I checked later at home and it still looked over to be honest.

1
Search forums: 

185 user(s) on-line: 0 registered and 185 guest(s)

Bookmark this page to:Add to Yahoo Bookmarks Add to Facebook Add to Ask Add to Blogmarks Add to Simpy Add to MyAOL Add to Delicious Add to Multiply Add to Link-a-Gogo Add to Faves Add to Twitter Add to Live Add to Furl Add to Mixx Add to Segnalo Add to Reddit Add to Terchnorati Add to StumbleUpon Add to Digg Add to Slashdot Add to Spurl Add to Yahoo MyWeb Add to Newsvine Add to MySpace Add to Diigo Add to Backflip Add to Mister Wong Add to Google Bookmarks

New - One price ADSL R169.00 - GET IT! - Cybersmart Internet Service Provider.

This web site uses Kentico CMS, the content management system for ASP.NET developers. Western Province Club Rugby