Community Site
HomeLinksNewsFixturesLogs & ResultsClub InfoGallerySite infoSocial MediaCape Rugby TVSign InEvox SponsorshipChat Zone
 
Chat Zone WP Club Rugby - Chat Zone
WP Club Rugby > Chat Zone > skeidsregters View modes: 
User avatar
Newbie
Newbie
viper01 - 08/06/2011 13:46:00
   
skeidsregters
hoekom gebruik die lyn regters en skeidsregters nie die tv skeidsregter
voordat hulle rooi en geel kaarte uitdeel nie dan kan elke betrokke persoon sien of hy skuldig is of die skeidsregter kan op gronde wat hy sien op tv n besluit maak wat reg of verkeerd is

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Josh K - 08/06/2011 16:53:30
   
RE:skeidsregters
I assume you are referring to internation rugby here?
Josh Kronfeld - half man half machine - A legend

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Jean - 08/06/2011 17:08:51
   
RE:skeidsregters
viper01 wrote: hoekom gebruik die lyn regters en skeidsregters nie die tv skeidsregter
voordat hulle rooi en geel kaarte uitdeel nie dan kan elke betrokke persoon sien of hy skuldig is of die skeidsregter kan op gronde wat hy sien op tv n besluit maak wat reg of verkeerd is


Goeie punt.

User avatar
Groupie
Groupie
gravy69 - 08/06/2011 22:10:05
   
RE:skeidsregters
Skeidsregters mag nie. TMO kan net gebruik word vir doelgebied.

User avatar
Newbie
Newbie
viper01 - 09/06/2011 07:24:43
   
RE:skeidsregters
josh k you sound like a guy that knows your rugby rules

where in the rule book is it written that match officials can not use tmo to
give red or yellow cards but they use the tmo for citings after wards 
does not make sence to me please help
 

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Josh K - 09/06/2011 10:02:37
   
RE:skeidsregters
That would be more IRB directive if Im not mistaken rather than IRB rule book. I would say I have to agree as it gives more clarity and makes sure you got the right guy in the end. The game is already full of stoppages , why not a little more .. its not like yellow and reds are taking over the game.
Josh Kronfeld - half man half machine - A legend

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Jean - 09/06/2011 11:42:34
   
RE:skeidsregters
Josh K wrote: That would be more IRB directive if Im not mistaken rather than IRB rule book. I would say I have to agree as it gives more clarity and makes sure you got the right guy in the end. The game is already full of stoppages , why not a little more .. its not like yellow and reds are taking over the game.


I agree

User avatar
Groupie
Groupie
gravy69 - 09/06/2011 12:09:59
   
RE:skeidsregters
Law 6.A.6 (b) clearly sets out when the TMO may be used by the referee.

User avatar
Master Member
Master Member
Eagles - 09/06/2011 12:31:18
   
RE:skeidsregters
Just to be clear, it's Rugby Laws not Rules.

User avatar
Groupie
Groupie
gravy69 - 10/06/2011 11:37:42
   
RE:skeidsregters
Viper - There is a citing commisioner at every game who does the citings and definately not the TMO. I suggest you get a law book to familiarize yourself with the laws. Don't believe everything the commentators are saying, because they also does not have a clue about the laws!

1
Search forums: 

194 user(s) on-line: 0 registered and 194 guest(s)

Bookmark this page to:Add to Yahoo Bookmarks Add to Facebook Add to Ask Add to Blogmarks Add to Simpy Add to MyAOL Add to Delicious Add to Multiply Add to Link-a-Gogo Add to Faves Add to Twitter Add to Live Add to Furl Add to Mixx Add to Segnalo Add to Reddit Add to Terchnorati Add to StumbleUpon Add to Digg Add to Slashdot Add to Spurl Add to Yahoo MyWeb Add to Newsvine Add to MySpace Add to Diigo Add to Backflip Add to Mister Wong Add to Google Bookmarks

New - One price ADSL R169.00 - GET IT! - Cybersmart Internet Service Provider.

This web site uses Kentico CMS, the content management system for ASP.NET developers. Western Province Club Rugby